A solution to B2B

Is dredging really a suitable alternative to dike works?

Dear Editor

In last week’s Golden Star every candidate for Council opposed to the B2B project suggested that dredging alone is the solution to minimising the flooding risk. The Town has published on their website two documents which identify that this understanding is incorrect and that both upgrading the dike and ongoing dredging will be required.

Quoting from the hydrological engineer’s report:

“… dredging work has a generally minor impact on upstream flood levels in the low dike section and does not eliminate the need to raise the dike.”  “…. Any mass over-excavation would soon fill in as it would just be a large trap. Hence bar excavations, when conditions dictate, is expected to be the ongoing practice to minimize the increase in downstream flood levels and prevent greater deposition from extending farther upstream to affect flood levels in the area between the bridges.”

From: “Options for Proceeding with Kicking Horse River Dyke Upgrade (Bridge to Bridge) Project”

Dredging vs. Dike Raising is not the simple either / or option it is being portrayed to be by those candidates opposed to the project and the “Say No to B2B” group.

The above document and the document “2012 Update Assessment of Sedimentation on The Kicking Horse River, Town of Golden” clearly:

Explain why dredging does not eliminate the need for dike works.

Explain why dredging of the fast flowing channel through town is not required or effective due to minimal accumulation in this area.

Demonstrate that the Town has a comprehensive and well-articulated plan for dredging. Explain the monitoring program that is in place to identify when dredging is required.

Explain the restrictions placed on the Town by senior levels of government with respect to dredging.

The “Say No to B2B” group have also suggested that dredging can be paid for by selling the gravel extracted. These documents make clear that BC Environment and DFO have stipulated that excavated gravel must not be sold and cannot be a source of revenue to the Town. This is therefore not an option. Those opposed to B2B who suggest that dredging alone is the solution to mitigating Golden’s flooding risk have either not read these documents or are willing to ignore the conclusions of the professional engineers that produced them. Either inference causes me concern.

There are many legitimate reasons that B2B should be critically considered including affordability, timing, and alignment with the Town’s identified priority action plan versus risk mitigation and improvement of area. However, it is time that those opposed to B2B stop suggesting dredging alone is an alternative to dike works. To continue using this argument is a cynical misrepresentation of facts that we too often see in Federal and Provincial politics. I would like to see these tactics kept out of our local politics.

Sincerely

Julian England

Golden

 

Just Posted

Freezing rain warning in effect for B.C. Southern Interior

Environment Canada issued the freezing rain warning for most of the Southern Interior Tuesday morning

Smiles all around as province announces emergency ward funding

$2.1 million to go to much-needed upgrades

As avalanche danger grows, BC heli-skiers exercise caution

Company relies on guides’ decades of experience

Heli-skiing operation “very concerned” by new caribou protection regs

Habitat protection is important, but ‘at what cost?’, asks Nakusp tourism operator.

Local artist brings his work to Art Gallery of Golden

A new art exhibit is coming to the Art Gallery of Golden and this one has a gentle PG advisory.

B.C. boy denied $19,000-per-month drug to ease ‘crippling pain’ for 3rd time

Sooke mom Jillian Lanthier says son Landen Alexa has been forgotten about by Premier John Horgan

Ice dancers Virtue and Moir to carry flag for Canada at 2018 Olympics

The pair earned a gold medal at the 2010 Vancouver Olympic Games

Diplomacy on agenda at North Korea summit in Vancouver

Foreign ministers from 20 countries are meeting Tuesday to discuss security and stability on the Korean Peninsula.

Kids chained in Calif. house of horrors; parents arrested

Authorities say an emaciated teenager led deputies to home where her 12 brothers and sisters were locked up in filthy conditions

‘Reprehensible’: Trudeau abortion policy raises ire of U.S. right

“This man is reprehensible,” tweeted former White House staffer Sebastian Gorka

‘I shouldn’t have to have a husband:’ Winnipeg woman criticizes men-only club

Jodi Moskal discovered the Winnipeg Squash Racquet Club continues to ban women as members, as it has done since opening in 1909.

Japan public TV sends mistaken North Korean missile alert

The false alarm came two days after Hawaii’s emergency management department sent a mistaken warning

Toronto girl dies after being pinned between vehicles while picked up from school

Police say an SUV with no driver in it rolled forward and pinned the girl against her father’s car

Most Read