A good talk

Following my letter to the Golden Star, Keith Hern and I met at the Farmers Market Wednesday evening to discuss it.

Following my letter to the Golden Star, Keith Hern and I met at the Farmers Market Wednesday evening to discuss it.

Below is a summary of our conversation identifying where we are in agreement and where our views differ on B2B.

First Keith and I talked about the dredging vs. dike raising question. Keith indicated that the Say NO to B2B group understand that this is not a one or the other question.

We both accept that ongoing dredging will be required even if the dike is raised.

I think it makes sense to raise the dike to at least the minimum of 0.6m above 200 year high water level recommneded by the Province.

The Say NO to B2B group are not opposed to raising the dike, however they want to see more analysis before accepting this proposal.

This was not something I, and others, have understood from their materials which I pointed out to Keith.

The Say No group also accept that the gravel cannot now be sold as it was in the past.

However, as Keith has pointed out the gravel can be stockpiled and used by the Town which produces significant budget savings.

Where Keith and I disagree is on next steps for the dike raising project.

I support the long term borrowing resolution as a way of getting the project moving while the current grant funds are available with the hope that the value engineering team can realise significant improvements to the proposed budget.

I am concerned that a NO vote will stall this process.

Keith and the Say NO group are concerned that the Town cannot afford this project at this time, that a complete list of priority projects does not yet exist, and that a YES vote will result in the proposed budget and solution becoming a foregone conclusion and that the value engineering team will not be robust enough to achieve real cost savings.

The Say NO group also believe that a properly constructed plan which includes bar scalping and gravel removal and dyke improvement could be negotiated under the existing grant. I think this is unlikely.

Keith and I are in very strong agreement on the following items:

1. Hydrological Modelling

More hydrological modelling is required to quantify the likely extent of flooding, potential impact and remediation costs.

Given the current construction of the dike it is highly unlikely that it will fail catastrophically and therefore the risk is of the river over topping the dike during high water events.

How long is this likely to occur for?

What depth of flood water would this result in across what area? This would be relatively simple to model using a number of scenarios and to our knowledge has not been done.

2. Value Engineering Team

That the value engineering team needs to be independent of Urban Systems.

As the proposer of the dike upgrade project solution and the fact that their fee is a percentage of total project cost Urban Systems are conflicted and not incentivised to look at more cost effective solutions.

They will also act as judge and jury on alternate solutions.

Council needs to take a leadership role in the composition and terms of reference for this team.

The currently proposed value engineering team structure is not adequate and risks being a rubber stamping organisation for the current proposal.

3. Asset Management Plan

That the work the Town is conducting on its asset management plan must be completed as soon as possible so that priorities can be established and overall long term funding requirements can be identified.

4. Flood Management Working Group

That a Flood Management Working Group (similar to the Air Quality Committee) needs to be established with a long term focus on both dike levels and gravel management, through dredging, to develop a holistic approach.


Julian England



Just Posted

New Glade ferry enters testing phase

The Glade II will be able to carry heavier loads and will use less greenhouse gases.

Freezing rain warning in effect for B.C. Southern Interior

Environment Canada issued the freezing rain warning for most of the Southern Interior Tuesday morning

Smiles all around as province announces emergency ward funding

$2.1 million to go to much-needed upgrades

As avalanche danger grows, BC heli-skiers exercise caution

Company relies on guides’ decades of experience

Heli-skiing operation “very concerned” by new caribou protection regs

Habitat protection is important, but ‘at what cost?’, asks Nakusp tourism operator.

VIDEO: Orcas put on a show near Hornby Island

Louis Jobodin shares photos and video of his experience

Trump aces mental aptitude test designed by Canadian immigrant

“This is a good example, I think, that will be helpful to change views about immigration. And maybe for Mr. Trump himself to consider immigrants as contributors to advancing science, advancing our societies.”

Rival Koreas agree to form first unified Olympic team

The rival Koreas took major steps toward reducing their bitter animosity

Canada, U.S. lead call for sanctions against North Korea

Foreign ministers from 20 countries are meeting in Vancouver to discuss security and stability on the Korean Peninsula

Federal NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh announces engagement

Federal NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh engaged to clothing designer Gurkiran Kaur

Hijab-cutting case highlights ethical issues with putting kids in spotlight

A Toronto police investigation has concluded a girl’s hijab was not cut by a scissors-wielding man as she walked to school

Change in politics, society on sexual misconduct ‘not fast enough,’ says Trudeau

Trudeau says society still lagging behind the systemic changes he is trying to make when it comes to preventing and responding to sexual harassment

Bank of Canada to make interest rate decision today

Economists widely believe that based on the economic environment, it’s likely interest rates will rise today

Body discovered in burnt out car near Trail

Police report a body was found in the burnt out trunk of a 1999 Honda Civic

Most Read